7 Mistakes You're Making When Someone Rolls Their Eyes at You (And How to Respond)

Eye rolling is one of those behaviors that can instantly make your blood boil. You're mid-sentence, making what you think is a perfectly reasonable point, and suddenly, there it is. That dramatic upward glance that seems to scream "you're being ridiculous."

It's natural to feel triggered when someone rolls their eyes at you. But here's what I've learned after years of working with couples and families: most people handle eye rolling in ways that actually make things worse, not better.
​
The truth is, eye rolling isn't just disrespect for the sake of disrespect. It's usually a signal that something deeper is going wrong in your communication. And when you respond poorly, you miss a critical opportunity to actually solve the real problem.

Mistake #1: Reacting Angrily or Defensively

This is the big one. The moment you see those eyes roll, your fight-or-flight kicks in. You feel attacked, so you attack back.

"Don't you roll your eyes at me!"
"That's so disrespectful!"
"I'm trying to help you here!"

Sound familiar? When you respond with anger, you're essentially confirming whatever frustration led to the eye roll in the first place. You're proving their point that this conversation isn't working.
​
What to do instead: Take a breath. I know it's hard, but that pause is everything. Notice your urge to defend yourself, then deliberately choose a different path. Your goal isn't to win, it's to understand what's really happening.

Mistake #2: Assuming You Know What the Eye Roll Means

Most people see an eye roll and immediately think "disrespect" or "attitude." But eye rolling can signal so many different things: boredom, disbelief, feeling unheard, frustration with the situation, or even feeling overwhelmed.

When you assume it's pure disrespect, you respond to the wrong problem. You start lecturing about respect when maybe they're actually feeling ignored or misunderstood.

What to do instead: Get curious instead of assuming. Ask neutral questions like "What are you thinking right now?" or "Am I missing something here?" Give them a chance to tell you what's really going on.

Mistake #3: Shutting Down and Walking Away

When someone rolls their eyes, some people do the opposite of getting angry, they shut down completely. They stop talking, walk away, or give the silent treatment.

This might feel like the mature response, but it's actually just as damaging. Eye rolling often happens when someone feels like they're not being heard. When you disengage, you confirm their worst fear: that you don't actually care about their perspective.

What to do instead: Stay in the conversation, even if it feels uncomfortable. Eye rolling might be their last attempt to get your attention before they give up entirely. Don't let that happen.

Mistake #4: Immediately Correcting or Reprimanding Them"Stop rolling your eyes at me."

"That behavior is unacceptable."
"We don't do that in this family."

Jumping straight to correction treats the symptom, not the cause. Yes, eye rolling isn't ideal communication. But if someone is frustrated enough to roll their eyes, telling them to stop isn't going to address what made them frustrated in the first place.
​
What to do instead: Address the underlying issue first, then circle back to communication styles later. Deal with the "why" before you tackle the "how."

Mistake #5: Not Creating Space for Them to Actually Express Themselves


Here's something most people don't realize: eye rolling often happens when someone has something to say but doesn't feel safe or welcomed to say it. Maybe they've tried to speak up before and been shut down. Maybe they feel like their opinion doesn't matter.

When you don't create space for them to vent or express their frustration, that eye roll might be the only way they feel they can communicate their feelings.

What to do instead: Ask genuinely, "What's going on for you right now? What am I not hearing?" Then, and this is crucial, actually listen to the answer without getting defensive.

Mistake #6: Interrupting When They Finally Start Talking

So they've rolled their eyes, you've asked what's wrong, and now they're finally opening up. But as soon as they start talking, you jump in with:

"Well, that's not what I meant..."
"You're being too sensitive..."
"Let me explain what actually happened..."

You've just wasted your opportunity. If someone is finally expressing their frustration, interrupting them will shut them right back down.

What to do instead: Let them vent completely before you respond. Use phrases like "I hear you" or "tell me more" to show you're listening, but resist the urge to defend yourself until they're completely finished.

Mistake #7: Approaching the Conversation Without Genuine Respect

This might be the most important one. If you're approaching this interaction feeling resentful, annoyed, or superior, they're going to sense that. And it's going to make everything worse.

When someone rolls their eyes, it's often because they feel disrespected or unheard. If your response comes from a place of "I'm the adult here" or "they need to learn respect," you're missing the point entirely.

What to do instead: Find genuine care and respect for this person's experience, even if you don't agree with how they're expressing it. Remember that their frustration is real, even if their expression of it isn't perfect.

The Better Way to Respond

When someone rolls their eyes at you, try this approach:

Step 1: Notice your initial reaction and pause.

Step 2: Get genuinely curious about what's happening for them.

Step 3: Ask something like, "It seems like something I said didn't land well. Can you help me understand what you're thinking?"

Step 4: Listen without defending. Let them express their frustration completely.

Step 5: Summarize what you heard to make sure they feel understood.

Step 6: Then, and only then, share your perspective or work together on a solution.

Why This Matters

Eye rolling isn't just about that moment. It's about the health of your relationship. When you respond to eye rolling with curiosity instead of defensiveness, you're sending a message that their feelings matter, that you want to understand them, and that your relationship is more important than being right.

This approach works whether you're dealing with your teenager, your partner, your coworker, or your friend. The goal isn't to eliminate all conflict or frustration: it's to handle it in a way that brings you closer together instead of driving you apart.

As therapist John Gottman says, "The goal of conflict resolution is not to solve the problem, but to have a conversation about the problem." Eye rolling is often a signal that the conversation isn't working. When you respond skillfully, you can get the conversation back on track.

Moving Forward

Remember, changing how you respond to eye rolling isn't just about that person: it's about you becoming a better communicator and a safer person to be in conflict with. These skills will serve you in every relationship you have.

If you're finding that eye rolling and communication conflicts are a recurring issue in your relationships, it might be helpful to work with a professional who can help you develop these skills in a more personalized way. Whether you're in California and can work with one of our therapists online or visit us in our Chico or Redding offices, or if you're in another state and need to find someone local, investing in better communication skills is one of the best things you can do for all your relationships.

Meet Our Staff

Book a Session!